What if Arya killed Cersei instead of Jaime? It’s one of the biggest “what if” scenarios that Game of Thrones fans still debate today. Imagine Arya Stark, with her unmatched stealth and deadly precision, finally crossing Cersei Lannister’s name off her infamous kill list. How would this shocking twist have changed the final chapters of the story? In this article, we dive deep into the possibilities, exploring how Arya’s assassination of Cersei could have reshaped alliances, legacies, and the fate of Westeros itself. Let’s reimagine this pivotal moment and the ripple effects it might have caused.
Arya’s Motivations and Skills: A Perfect Assassin
Arya Stark’s desire for revenge against the Lannisters, particularly Cersei, stems from the traumatic experience of witnessing her father’s unjust execution at the hands of the Lannisters. This event deeply affected Arya and fueled her determination to seek retribution. Over time, she honed her skills in combat and espionage to exact her revenge, showing unwavering determination in her pursuit. Arya’s long-standing animosity toward the Lannisters serves as a driving force in her character development, shaping her journey and motivations throughout the series.
In The Red Wedding, Arya Stark’s role was pivotal as she witnessed the brutal massacre of her family members and experienced the devastating loss of loved ones. This traumatic event fueled her journey of vengeance across multiple seasons as she sought retribution for her family’s betrayal and murder. Arya’s transition from a naive girl to a deadly assassin was a result of her harrowing experiences and the guidance she received from various mentors, such as Syrio Forel and Jaqen H’ghar. She honed her skills in combat and deception, ultimately becoming a formidable force to be reckoned with. Throughout her journey, Arya faced numerous challenges and obstacles that tested her resilience and determination.
Arya’s training with the Faceless Men in the art of stealth, assassination, and disguise has equipped her with a unique set of skills that would have made her exceptionally qualified to kill Cersei. Her ability to seamlessly blend into her surroundings and assume different identities would have allowed her to get close to Cersei without raising suspicion. Additionally, her proficiency in the use of poisons and her agility in combat would have made her a formidable opponent. Overall, Arya’s training and abilities make her a highly effective and dangerous assassin, making her a strong contender for the task of killing Cersei.
It would have made sense for Arya to take on this mission, considering her journey toward personal growth and independence. Throughout her experiences, she has developed a strong sense of determination and courage, which are valuable traits for someone undertaking a challenging mission. Additionally, this mission could have provided Arya with an opportunity to further develop her skills and prove her capabilities as a capable and independent individual. Overall, given her character development and strengths, it would have been logical for Arya to take on this mission.
Cersei’s End: A Reversal of the Prophecy
Arya’s role could potentially alter the prophecy in a few ways. As a skilled assassin, Arya could have been the one to fulfill the prophecy by killing Cersei instead of Jaime. This would still fulfill the prophecy of Cersei’s death at the hands of her younger brother, as Arya is younger than Cersei. Additionally, Arya’s presence could have influenced the events leading up to Cersei’s death, potentially changing the circumstances and timing of how the prophecy plays out. Ultimately, Arya’s role could have added a new layer of complexity to the prophecy and its fulfillment.
Being killed by Arya, a Stark, would have a significant psychological impact on Cersei. It would symbolize the ultimate defeat at the hands of her enemies, as well as the destruction of her legacy and power. Facing death at the hands of a member of the family she has long considered her enemy would likely cause Cersei to feel a deep sense of betrayal and humiliation. In contrast, Jaime’s death would likely have a different psychological impact on Cersei. While still devastating, it would not carry the same symbolic weight of being killed by an enemy from a rival family. Instead, it would likely cause Cersei to feel a profound sense of loss and grief for the person she loved.
Impact on Jaime Lannister’s Arc
Jaime Lannister’s redemption journey was framed as a gradual transition from a villainous character to a more morally complex and ultimately sympathetic figure. His development was shaped by his experiences, relationships, and internal struggles, ultimately leading to a more nuanced understanding of his actions and choices. If Arya had killed Cersei instead of Jaime, it would have undoubtedly had a significant impact on his character development. Without Cersei’s influence and their complex relationship, Jaime may have been forced to confront his own identity and motivations in a different way. His redemption arc may have taken a different form, but it is likely that he would still have been given the opportunity to seek redemption and evolve as a character.
Jaime’s emotional consequences for both scenarios would be complex. On one hand, his love and loyalty to Cersei might drive him to go to King’s Landing to try and save her, despite the risks. However, if he were to witness Arya taking his twin sister’s life, he would likely experience a deep sense of shock, grief, and potentially even anger. It’s difficult to predict how he would react in the moment, as it would be a highly emotional and traumatic experience for him. As for whether he would choose to die with Cersei or survive to face a different fate, that would depend on the events leading up to that moment and the inner turmoil he would be grappling with.
Arya’s Revenge: Political and Social Ramifications in Westeros
If Arya were to kill Cersei, it would undoubtedly have a significant impact on the political landscape of Westeros. With Cersei out of the picture, the Lannister hold on the Iron Throne would be broken, paving the way for a power struggle among various factions. It is difficult to predict who would rise to power in the aftermath as there are several contenders, including Daenerys Targaryen, Jon Snow, and potentially other noble houses vying for the throne. Arya’s actions could potentially shift the balance of power and create an opportunity for a different ruler to ascend to the Iron Throne.
Cersei’s death at Arya’s hands could potentially create a power vacuum in the Seven Kingdoms. With the Lannister dynasty potentially destroyed or weakened, there is the possibility of new conflicts arising as different factions vie for control. The resurgence of old power structures or the rise of new leaders, like Tyrion, could further destabilize the political landscape. As for Arya’s role in the politics of Westeros, it is uncertain whether she would want to take on a leadership role after avenging her family. Arya has shown reluctance towards traditional leadership and has often preferred to operate outside the political fray. However, her actions could potentially propel her into a leadership position, especially if her actions are seen as heroic and inspiring.
The Stark Family and Arya’s Relationship with Sansa and Jon
Sansa and Arya’s relationship would likely be impacted significantly if Arya were to kill Cersei. Sansa may have mixed feelings about Arya’s act of vengeance – on one hand, she may understand Arya’s desire to seek justice for their family, but on the other hand, she may worry about the consequences and the toll it could take on Arya’s soul. Arya’s decision would definitely deepen and complicate their sibling bond, as Sansa would have to grapple with conflicting emotions and the moral implications of Arya’s actions. In the show’s final seasons, Sansa and Arya’s dynamic evolved from one of conflict and misunderstanding to one of mutual respect and understanding.
A Different Ending for Daenerys Targaryen
Without the destruction of King’s Landing, Daenerys’ arc may have unfolded differently. It’s possible that she may not have become the “Mad Queen” and instead had a different kind of showdown with the remaining power players in Westeros. The fate of the Iron Throne would also be affected if Arya were to kill Cersei. It’s possible that the throne could still become a symbol of unity, or it could dissolve altogether as various factions seek power. In this scenario, a “good” ruler would likely be someone who is able to bring peace and stability to the realm, and it’s uncertain who might be the one to ascend the throne.
Arya’s Legacy and the Greater Impact on Westeros
Arya’s actions as a killer certainly leave a lasting impact on the history of Westeros. Her killing of Cersei could potentially elevate her to a legendary status, with some viewing her as a hero of justice for ridding the realm of a tyrant. However, others may see her as a villain who took the life of an important queen. The ripple effect on Westeros would be significant, as the consequences of Arya’s actions would shape the future of the realm. Future generations may view her act of revenge in different ways, with some believing it brought peace by removing a dangerous ruler, while others may see it as sparking more conflict and war.
Conclusion
In the article, we explored Arya’s motivations for seeking revenge on Cersei for her father’s death, and the implications this would have for Jaime Lannister, who killed her father. We also discussed the political consequences of Arya’s actions and how the story’s end would be radically different if she had succeeded in her quest for vengeance. Reflecting on the nature of vengeance, justice, and legacy in Game of Thrones, it is a complex and multi-layered issue. While Arya’s revenge may seem fitting for her character, it could also have brought unforeseen consequences for Westeros, potentially perpetuating a cycle of violence and further destabilizing the political landscape.